🍕 New Jersey’s Best Independent Pizzerias
Published: November 2025
By: Editor
Tags: pizza, artisan, independent, local business, New Jersey
From coal-fired classics to creative pies, discover New Jersey’s best pizza destinations.
Across 20 independent pizzerias—from Passaic to Cape May—you’ll find everything from old-school tomato pies in Mercer County to wood-fired masterpieces along the Shore. Each of these local favorites combines craftsmanship, character, and community—proof that Jersey’s pizza pride runs deep.
➡️ Explore our full New Jersey Pizza Directory for more local favorites.
đź—» North Jersey
Quality Pizza Co. Hoboken (Hoboken)
This Hoboken favorite turns out crisp-edged, airy pies that blend tradition with creativity in a relaxed neighborhood setting.
Try: Margherita pie, truffle mushroom slice, garlic knots.
“Perfect balance of crunch and flavor—my go-to pizza in Hoboken.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
Ellison Pizza & Deli (Paterson)
A Paterson institution serving hearty New York-style slices and Italian comfort food with old-school charm.
Try: Sausage and pepperoni pie or a crispy white pizza with ricotta and spinach.
“Always hot, fresh, and loaded with flavor—best pizza in Paterson!” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
IL Gusto Pizzeria & Italian (Andover)
At IL Gusto, each pizza is made with hand-stretched dough and locally sourced ingredients, baked to perfection in a cozy, rustic setting.
Try: Grandma pie, white pizza with spinach, tiramisu.
“Authentic Italian taste—every visit feels like family dinner night.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
Wahizza Pizzeria & Restaurant (Italian–Dominican) (Ridgefield Park)
Fusing Italian tradition with Dominican flair, Wahizza stands out for bold flavors and a lively atmosphere.
Try: Pepperoni and plantain pie or penne alla vodka pizza.
“The best of both worlds—Italian meets Dominican in the most delicious way!” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
Lodi Pizza Restaurant (Lodi)
A Bergen County classic beloved for its no-frills charm and old-school slices that have fed generations.
Try: Classic cheese slice, sausage and peppers pie, zeppoles.
“Been coming here for decades—same great taste and friendly service.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
Jimmy Tomato’s and Bombay Curry Pizza (Denville)
A globally inspired menu where New Jersey pizza meets Indian spice for unique yet balanced flavors.
Try: Bombay curry chicken pizza or garlic naan-crust pie.
“Unexpected but amazing—flavors that just work!” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
Cambiotti’s Tomato Pie Café (Roxbury Township)
Morris County gem known for its signature tomato pies—thin, tangy, and loaded with fresh sauce in true Jersey style.
Try: Tomato pie, buffalo chicken pizza, cannoli.
“Classic Jersey tomato pie done right—crispy crust and sweet sauce perfection.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
🏙️ Central Jersey
Del Porto Italian Restaurant (Elizabeth)
Combining fine Italian dining with neighborhood warmth, Del Porto serves Neapolitan-style pizzas alongside handmade pasta and wine pairings.
Try: Margherita D.O.C., prosciutto arugula pie, tiramisu.
“Upscale feel without pretension—some of the best pizza and service in Jersey.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
The Smoke (Hamilton)
A local standout for wood-fired pizza, The Smoke blends charred crusts and smoky aromas for a laid-back but elevated experience.
Try: Smoked mozzarella pie or spicy soppressata pizza.
“Flavor and crust are unreal—pizza with real character.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
Sizzle n' Slice – Pizza & Wings (North Brunswick Township)
True to its name, Sizzle n' Slice delivers fresh pies and saucy wings in a fun, sports-bar setting perfect for families.
Try: Buffalo chicken pizza or garlic knots.
“Always hot, fresh, and perfectly seasoned—our Friday night favorite.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pies (Robbinsville Township)
A Mercer County legend, De Lorenzo’s has perfected the tomato pie for nearly a century with its signature sauce-first layering.
Try: Plain tomato pie or pepperoni tomato pie.
“Every bite is perfection—true New Jersey pizza royalty.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
Papa’s Tomato Pies (Robbinsville Township)
America’s oldest continuously run pizzeria still serves thin, well-balanced pies from its original family recipe.
Try: Mustard pie or sausage and onion pizza.
“Historic, delicious, and authentically Jersey.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
Villaggio Iccara (Hamilton Township)
Elegant Italian fare with wood-fired pizzas as its centerpiece and an impressive wine selection to match.
Try: Burrata pizza or truffle white pie.
“Beautiful presentation and even better taste—Hamilton’s hidden gem.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
🌅 South Jersey
Riccardo’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant (Pemberton Township)
A South Jersey favorite for hearty pies and Italian classics served with friendly small-town hospitality.
Try: Margherita pizza or ricotta calzone.
“Big portions and bold flavor—always made with care.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
IL Fuoco Dentro (Harrison Township)
Specializing in wood-fired pies baked at searing temperatures, IL Fuoco Dentro crafts blistered, aromatic pizzas full of rustic charm.
Try: Margherita D.O.P. or roasted mushroom pie.
“True artisan pizza—every bite tastes straight out of Italy.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
Zio Niccolo Pizza (Sea Isle City)
This coastal pizzeria pairs laid-back beach vibes with high-quality ingredients and generous portions.
Try: Sicilian pie or buffalo chicken pizza.
“Always a must-stop when we’re down the shore!” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
Village Idiot Brewing Company (Mount Holly)
Pair a local craft beer with a freshly baked artisan pizza in this community taproom.
Try: Beer-braised sausage pizza or pretzel bites.
“Fun spot with great pizza and even better brews.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
Nick’s Pizzeria (Pilesgrove)
Small-town favorite serving generous slices and crispy pies that keep locals coming back.
Try: Meat lovers or stromboli.
“Friendly service and delicious pies—classic South Jersey charm.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
Nino’s Family Restaurant (Middle Township)
Family-run Cape May County favorite known for classic Italian dinners and hand-tossed pizzas that draw locals and tourists alike.
Try: Pepperoni pizza or shrimp scampi pie.
“Authentic Italian flavor and friendly service—always hits the spot.” – Google Review
➡️ View Information
❤️ Why These Made the List
Every pizzeria here earned its place through craftsmanship, local love, and consistent quality. From historic tomato-pie traditions to modern fusion flavors, these spots showcase the passion and pride that define New Jersey’s independent pizza scene.
We prioritize:
- Authenticity: Independent owners using hand-crafted methods
- Quality: High ratings and consistent execution
- Local Impact: Community roots and neighborhood support
- Accessibility: Welcoming spaces for all pizza lovers
🧠Plan Your Pizza Crawl
North Route: From Passaic to Hudson, enjoy airy crusts and artisan flavors.
Central Loop: Hamilton and Robbinsville deliver tomato-pie heritage and modern twists.
South Trail: From Gloucester to Cape May, enjoy coastal favorites and family-run gems.
💡 Pro tip: Call ahead for specials—many offer seasonal pies or farm-fresh toppings.
âť“ FAQ
How were these pizzerias selected?
Through verified ratings, editorial research, and community recommendations.
Are they ranked?
No rankings—each is listed by region for easy planning.
Can I suggest a spot?
Yes! Nominate your favorite independent pizzeria on our contact page.
Do businesses pay to be featured?
Never. Every listing is earned through merit and reputation.
✍️ Editor’s Note
This guide was compiled through verified ratings, editorial research, and local insights. We’ll update as new standouts emerge.
Last updated: November 2025 Updated by: Best NJ Food
Support local. Eat well. Explore New Jersey.
➡️ Explore our full New Jersey Pizza Directory for more local favorites.
🛡️ Why You Can Trust This Guide
Independently researched and curated — Every business is evaluated on merit, not payment.
No business can pay to be included — All listings are earned through quality and reputation.
Based on verified reviews and local reputation — We prioritize real feedback from New Jersey residents.
Regularly updated for accuracy — We re-check each business to keep recommendations current.