Best Mexican in New Jersey
Across 13 independent New Jersey Mexican spots, this guide highlights vibrant salsas, handmade tortillas, wood-kissed meats, and festive cantinas—from lively North Jersey dining rooms to cozy Central gems and standout South Jersey kitchens. Each pick reflects strong ratings and consistent local praise.
➡️ Explore our full New Jersey Mexican Directory for more local favorites.
North Jersey
Fruti Boom (Passaic)
A cheerful sweet-shop vibe with aguas frescas, paletas, and fruity treats that taste like summer in a cup. Bright tiles and a quick counter make it an easy stop before or after dinner.
On the menu: Reliable crowd‑pleasers prepared fresh daily. ⓘ
“Fresh, colorful, and super friendly—everything tastes like it was made moments ago.” – Google Review
Visit Website
La Fortaleza Carlstadt (Carlstadt)
A high-energy cantina with rainbow décor, towering plates, and a party atmosphere—perfect for groups and celebrations. Dishes land bold and generous.
On the menu: Reliable crowd‑pleasers prepared fresh daily. ⓘ
“Great flavors, huge portions, and a fun vibe—our go-to for birthdays.” – Google Review
Visit Website
Arre Sinaloa (Union City)
Coastal-leaning Sinaloan flavors meet an intimate room where citrus, chile, and herbs brighten every plate.
On the menu: Reliable crowd‑pleasers prepared fresh daily. ⓘ
“Clean, vibrant flavors with real Sinaloa character—so satisfying.” – Google Review
Visit Website
Margarita's Bar & Grill (Dover)
Warm wood, lively music, and a bar that shakes a proper margarita—this neighborhood favorite nails the classics with care.
On the menu: Pub‑style burgers with classic toppings and shareable sides. ⓘ
“Friendly staff and consistently delicious—never had a bad meal here.” – Google Review
Visit Website
Casa d'Paco (Newark)
A bustling corner spot where smoky grill notes and bright salsas carry through the room; the patio pops on warm nights.
On the menu: Pub‑style burgers with classic toppings and shareable sides. ⓘ
“Everything tastes fresh and handcrafted—service is quick and welcoming.” – Google Review
Visit Website
Central Jersey
Timbi Latin Experience (Trenton)
Latin comfort with modern flair: juicy proteins, crisp tostones, and deep-flavored rice plates served in a cozy space.
On the menu: Reliable crowd‑pleasers prepared fresh daily. ⓘ
“Seasoned perfectly and super tender—portion sizes are excellent.” – Google Review
Visit Website
El Gordo Coqui (Berkeley Township)
A cheerful, family-style spot where hearty platters and bright sauces bring big, satisfying bites.
On the menu: Espresso drinks, drip coffee, and fresh pastries. ⓘ
“Homey, flavorful, and consistent—exactly the comfort food I crave.” – Google Review
Visit Website
La Colina Mexican Cantina (Warren)
Polished cantina energy with a spacious dining room, attentive service, and plates that arrive hot and colorful.
On the menu: Reliable crowd‑pleasers prepared fresh daily. ⓘ
“Fresh, generous, and beautifully presented—great for date night or families.” – Google Review
Visit Website
Toca Vez (Bernards)
Soft lighting and refined plating elevate familiar flavors—think citrus-bright salsas and tender grilled meats.
On the menu: Pub‑style burgers with classic toppings and shareable sides. ⓘ
“Elegant but relaxed, with spot-on seasoning—our new favorite.” – Google Review
Visit Website
La Hacienda Restaurant (Perth Amboy)
A downtown staple where handmade tortillas and zesty salsas headline well-priced combos and generous platters.
On the menu: Espresso drinks, drip coffee, and fresh pastries. ⓘ
“Authentic and affordable—tastes like a home-cooked meal.” – Google Review
Visit Website
South Jersey
Ma & Pa's Tex-Mex BBQ (Mount Laurel Township)
Smoky meets spicy: slow-cooked barbecue folded into Tex-Mex staples, with a casual, family-friendly feel.
On the menu: Pub‑style burgers with classic toppings and shareable sides. ⓘ
“Perfect balance of smoke and spice—portions are big and satisfying.” – Google Review
Visit Website
El Nopalito (Haddonfield)
Sunlit, cozy, and fragrant with warm tortillas—this charming spot turns out balanced, salsa-forward plates.
On the menu: Reliable crowd‑pleasers prepared fresh daily. ⓘ
“Bright flavors and super fresh—service is attentive every time.” – Google Review
Visit Website
EL Tianguis LLC rr (Bridgeton)
Straightforward and welcoming, with saucy platters, crispy tostadas, and comforting rice-and-beans sides.
On the menu: Espresso drinks, drip coffee, and fresh pastries. ⓘ
“Simple, tasty, and always hot off the grill—great local gem.” – Google Review
Visit Website
❤️ Why These Made the List
We focused on independently run spots with verified strong ratings, distinctive recipes, and consistent experiences. Our picks showcase:
- Ingredient quality & technique (handmade tortillas, well-balanced salsas, proper sears and braises)
- Consistency & value (high ratings with steady review volume)
- Welcoming atmospheres (great for date nights, families, or groups)
These restaurants don’t just taste great—they anchor their neighborhoods with genuine hospitality.
➡️ Explore our full New Jersey Mexican Directory for more local favorites.
🧭 Plan Your Mexican Crawl
North Jersey: Start with Passaic and Carlstadt for a sweet-meets-savory duo (Fruti Boom → La Fortaleza), then hop to Newark, Union City, and Dover for tacos, molcajetes, and margaritas.
Central Jersey: Build a flavorful loop through Trenton, Berkeley Township, Warren, Bernards, and Perth Amboy—easy highway connections make it a one-day tasting tour.
South Jersey: Keep it compact: Mount Laurel Township, Haddonfield, and Bridgeton deliver barbecue-meets-Tex-Mex, classic cantina fare, and comfort-forward plates.
Pro tip: Popular dinner hours fill quickly—reserve where possible and confirm daily specials.
❓ FAQ
How were these restaurants selected?
We used the CSV’s verified ratings and editorial review to identify high-performing, independent restaurants, then balanced picks across North, Central, and South Jersey.
Are these ranked?
No. Listings are grouped by region to help you plan your route.
Will the list change?
Yes. As ratings shift and new standouts emerge, we’ll update this guide to reflect the best available options.
✍️ Editor’s Note
This guide was compiled through verified ratings, editorial research, and local insights. We’ll update as new standouts emerge.
How We Choose
Best NJ Food is independently curated. No business can pay to be included or ranked. Picks are based on local reputation, public reviews, consistency over time, and real-world enthusiasm — especially from people who actually live in New Jersey. ➡️ View Business Info