Across 20 independent bagel shops—from Bergen County to Cape May—bakers are boiling, baking, and serving some of the state’s most satisfying breakfast staples. At Best NJ Food, we’ve curated these standout spots for freshness, craft, and community charm.
🗻 North Jersey
Bagel Supreme of Oakland (Oakland)
A Bergen County staple where bagels come out hot, glossy, and perfectly chewy straight from the oven.
"Very welcoming and superb customer service. Clean, with lots of vegetarian and vegan options!" — Google Review
"Great bagel spot with an extensive menu — the Taylor ham and egg on an egg bagel was excellent." — Google Review ⓘ
Knead A Bagel (Ho-Ho-Kus)
Small-town warmth meets artisan precision—each batch is hand-rolled and kettle-boiled daily.
"Super tasty bagels and the friendliest service!" — Google Review
"Amazingly kind staff, great food, and overall a nice place to spend time in." — Google Review ⓘ
House of Bagels (Verona)
Family-owned favorite in Essex County known for chewy texture and golden crusts.
"Bagels are soft and chewy on the inside and have a nice crust on the outside — my go-to for breakfast." — Google Review
"Always fresh and delicious. Can't beat the price or the quality." — Google Review ⓘ
Hamburg Hot Bagels (Hamburg)
Locals line up early for oversized bagels and hearty breakfast sandwiches served with a smile.
"Freshest bagels around — always warm, soft, and full of flavor." — Google Review
"Great staff and quick service. The bacon, egg, and cheese is top-tier." — Google Review ⓘ
B Bagels (Jersey City)
A sleek downtown spot turning out chewy bagels and inventive cream-cheese flavors for the urban crowd.
"Best bagels in Jersey City, hands down — always fresh and chewy." — Google Review
"Great vibe, delicious bagels, and cozy seating — a perfect brunch spot." — Google Review
Bagel Station (Sparta)
Sussex County’s no-frills gem serving handmade bagels and strong coffee since the ’90s.
"Been coming here for years — still the best bagels in Sussex County." — Google Review
"Simple menu done right — you can taste the freshness." — Google Review
Teaneck Road Hot Bagels (Teaneck)
A family-run favorite for decades, known for generous sandwiches and soft-crust bagels fresh off the board.
"Excellent bagels — crispy on the outside, soft inside, and always fresh." — Google Review
"Great place for salmon lox bagels with friendly service and fair prices." — Google Review
🏙️ Central Jersey
Deerpath Bagels & Burgers & Boba Tea (Hamilton Township)
Bright and creative café pairing traditional bagels with unexpected twists—yes, even bubble tea.
"Such a fun mix — great bagels, burgers, and bubble tea! Friendly staff and super clean." — Google Review
"I love the creativity here — never thought I'd get a bagel and boba in one stop!" — Google Review ⓘ
Ewing Bagel Shop (Ewing Township)
A small plaza spot that impresses with freshness, warmth, and quick service.
"Simple and cozy spot with some of the freshest bagels in the area." — Google Review
"Local gem — the coffee is strong and the bagels are consistently good." — Google Review ⓘ
City Bagel Cafe (Flemington)
A community hub for hearty breakfast sandwiches and espresso in a sunny storefront.
"Awesome breakfast sandwiches and lattes — everything is top-notch." — Google Review
"Friendly owners who clearly care about their food and customers." — Google Review ⓘ
Bagel Bar (Rahway)
Union County newcomer that nails the balance between crisp crust and soft chew.
"Love this place — fresh bagels, great coffee, and quick service." — Google Review
"The best spot in Union County for bagels — hands down." — Google Review ⓘ
Del Pino Bakery & Deli (Elizabeth)
Part bakery, part bagel stop—warm pastries and classic New York-style bagels under one roof.
"Fresh bagels and pastries made daily — everything smells amazing when you walk in." — Google Review
"The mix of Latin pastries and New York-style bagels is awesome." — Google Review ⓘ
Tottenville Bagels Avenel Nj (Woodbridge Township)
Central Jersey mainstay offering big portions and true deli-style service.
"Classic Jersey bagel shop — the Taylor ham sandwich is incredible." — Google Review
"Friendly service and great coffee — can't go wrong here." — Google Review ⓘ
🌅 South Jersey
Bagels & Market Mount Laurel (Mount Laurel Township)
A bright, modern café turning out picture-perfect bagels and hearty brunch plates.
"Fresh, soft bagels with a great selection of spreads." — Google Review
"Love their asiago bagel egg sandwich and coffee combo." — Google Review ⓘ
Hudah Babylon Bagel and Restaurant (Washington Township)
Gloucester County café combining Mediterranean breakfast plates with top-notch bagels.
"Mediterranean twist on classic bagels — so unique and delicious." — Google Review
"Clean restaurant with a huge menu — everything we tried was amazing." — Google Review ⓘ
Harbor Coffee House (Middle Township)
A coastal café pairing espresso drinks with small-batch bagels baked on-site.
"Relaxed beach vibe and friendly staff — the bagels are baked fresh daily." — Google Review
"Love the breakfast sandwiches and cold brew combo." — Google Review ⓘ
Poppy Bagels & More (Galloway)
Homestyle favorites served in a cheerful family atmosphere with bottomless coffee.
"Best bagels in the area — light, chewy, and fresh." — Google Review
"Family-run place that makes you feel right at home." — Google Review ⓘ
Hot Bagels & More 1996 (Somers Point)
A Shore classic known for soft bagels, hearty sandwiches, and fast lines.
"Soft, fresh bagels every morning — great pre-beach stop." — Google Review
"Friendly and quick — love this spot before heading to the beach." — Google Review ⓘ
Magic Brain Cafe (Cape May)
Artisan coffee and small-batch bagels served in a cozy downtown nook steps from the ocean.
"Cozy café with great coffee and homemade bagels." — Google Review
"Feels like a local secret — quiet, warm, and welcoming." — Google Review ⓘ
Bagel Express Food Mart (Eastampton Township)
A local favorite in Burlington County serving fresh bagels and breakfast sandwiches with friendly service.
"A hidden gem — small shop with big flavor." — Google Review
"Great place for a classic Jersey breakfast — never disappoints." — Google Review ⓘ
❤️ Why These Made the List
Best NJ Food is independently curated — no business can pay to be featured.
Our picks reflect community reputation, verified reviews, long-term consistency, and local impact.
We prioritize:
- Authenticity: Independent bakeries and small-batch methods
- Quality: High ratings and flavor balance
- Local Impact: Shops that support their neighborhoods
- Accessibility: Welcoming spaces for everyone
These bagel shops aren’t just breakfast stops — they’re part of what makes New Jersey special.
🧭 Plan Your Bagel Crawl
**North Route:** Start in Bergen and Essex for classic NY-style bagels and strong coffee.
**Central Loop:** Union and Mercer offer creative takes and new-school flavors.
**South Trail:** From Gloucester to Cape May, find warm coastal bakeries and Mediterranean twists.
💡 *Pro tip:* Arrive early — most sell out before noon!
❓ FAQ
**How were these bagel shops selected?**
Through verified ratings, editorial research, and community recommendations.
**Are they ranked?**
No — each shop shines in its own way. Listings are by region for easy planning.
**Can I suggest a new spot?**
Yes! Use our contact page to nominate your favorite independent bagel shop.
**Do businesses pay to be featured?**
Never. Every listing is earned through merit and reputation.
✍️ Editor’s Note
This guide was compiled through verified ratings, editorial research, and local insights.
We’ll update as new standouts emerge.
_Last updated: November 2025_
_Updated by: Best NJ Food_
Support local. Eat well. Explore New Jersey.